Bachelor In Paradise season 10 premieres in 2025, and there are ten men from The Bachelorette season 21 who deserve a second chance at love if they don’t get engaged to Jenn Tran in the end. Bachelor Nation was devastated when Bachelor in Paradise was absent from both the 2024 ABC summer and fall schedules, which lead to speculation that the beloved show had been canceled. However, in July 2024, ABC announced that Bachelor in Paradise will return in 2025 for its tenth season.
Jenn, a 26-year-old physician assistant student originally from Hillsdale, New Jersey, but currently living in Boston, Massachusetts, is still looking for love on The Bachelorette season 21, but there are several men on the show who’d be perfect as Bachelor in Paradise season 10 contestants. She’s already said goodbye to some, while others are still competing for her heart. Although it’s still possible that any of her remaining suitors could get engaged to her in the end, here are ten men who deserve a second chance at love if they don’t get end up with Jenn.
1Brett Harris – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Jenn Sent Brett Home On Night One
Bachelor Nation was thrilled when The Bachelorette season 21 cast was announced, and they saw Brett, a 28-year-old health and safety manager from Manheim, Pennsylvania, representing a different body type in the cast. They were excited to see what Brett would bring to the table, and they weren’t disappointed. The teddy bear did a split on The Bachelorette premiere night, showcasing his fun personality. However, Brett didn’t make a strong enough impression on Jenn to receive a rose, and she sent him home on night one.
Like Bachelor Nation fan favorite Joe Amabile, who was eliminated by Becca Kufrin during her premiere, Brett is a night one elimination who captured fans’ hearts. People just want to know more about him and want to see him find love. Brett deserves another chance to search for love on the beaches of Mexico. If he doesn’t get one, there’s a long line of women willing to give him a second chance at love.
2Devin Strader – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Devin Isn’t Afraid To Fall In Love
Devin, a 28-year-old freight company owner from Houston, Texas, has one of the biggest personalities on The Bachelorette season 21. Although he’s a frontrunner who seems to be on the path to winning Jenn’s heart, Devin’s outgoing personality has rubbed many of his fellow contestants the wrong way, including Aaron Erb, Sam McKinney, and Thomas Nguyen. However, Devin seems to be a good man who genuinely wants to fall in love.
Like The Bachelorette season 20 star Brayden Bowers before him, Devin has the potential to be one of the most loved Bachelor in Paradise contestants. Brayden also clashed with his fellow Bachelorette contestants, but, on the Bachelor in Paradise beach, he won them over with his fun personality and kind demeanor. They were all the best of friends before the season ended, and the same could happen for Devin. In addition, Devin is ready to fall in love, and he told Jenn that he was falling for her, and that he wasn’t afraid to say it. If he doesn’t get engaged to her, he deserves another chance in Paradise.
3Jonathon Johnson – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Jonathon Is The Life Of The Party
Jonathon is a 27-year-old creative director from Los Angeles, California. With his great smile and fun personality, Jonathon would be the life of the party on the beach. He arrived on Jenn’s premiere night wearing nothing but a hospital gown and sneakers, with his face completely wrapped in bandages. It was a creative way to catch Jenn’s attention, as he kept her in suspense for the whole night before revealing his face to her. Jonathon also won the male stripper revue group date contest and set up a lacrosse game for him and Jenn because they’d both played in college.
Bachelor in Paradise is a wild show, and Jonathon has proven that he’s up for anything. However, he also has a sweet and sensitive side that would make him a very romantic contestant as well. If Jonathon and Jenn don’t get engaged, he should definitely make a trip to Mexico for a second chance at love.
4Grant Ellis – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Grant Wants To Be A Husband & A Father
Grant, a 30-year-old day trader from Houston, Texas, is the perfect Bachelor in Paradise contestant. He’s respectful of his fellow Bachelorette season 21 contestants, and has been the voice of reason in some of their arguments. Most importantly, Grant wants to be a husband and a father. He told Jenn that he was so ready for it and he couldn’t wait to someday come home and have his children run to him, saying that daddy’s home.
It’s easy to imagine Grant as the type of man who’d leave Bachelor in Paradise engaged. Not only is he romantic and ready to be engaged, but he has a fun side that he showcased when he played basketball with Jenn on premiere night. If he doesn’t end up with Jenn, there are surely many women who’d love to meet him in Paradise. However, Grant might actually be even better suited to be the next star of The Bachelor.
5Dylan Buckor – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Dylan Is Becoming More Confident
Dylan, a 24-year-old medical student from Elk Grove, California, is the youngest Bachelorette season 21 contestant. Although he admitted to Jenn that he initially thought that maybe he couldn’t compete with all of the amazing guys on her season, after she chose him for some one-on-one time on a group date, and they kissed, his confidence soared. Dylan is a sweet and self-admittedly shy guy who deserves to find his person. Although he’s shy, he also has an adventurous side, which he showed on the group date when he stepped in to take a photo with a terrified Jenn and a python, which he wrapped around his neck.
If Jenn and Dylan don’t get engaged at the end of The Bachelorette season 21, then Dylan should definitely try his luck in Paradise. It might be easier for him if there aren’t so many other guys competing for the same woman. Dylan would be the type of guy who’d meet someone on day one and stay with her until the end. Bachelor in Paradise could definitely work for someone like Dylan.
6Spencer Conley – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Spencer Deserves Love After His Past Heartache
Spencer, a 30-year-old pet portrait entrepreneur from Dallas, Texas, came to The Bachelorette season 21 following a serious heartbreak that occurred four years before, when he found out that his fiancée had been cheating on him. He admitted to Jenn that he had a rough time after that, but he was now “more ready than ever to be engaged again” after learning everything he had about himself over the past four years. He so deserves it.
Throughout Jenn’s season so far, Spencer has proven himself to be a gentleman. On their one-on-one date, he buckled her seat belt in the helicopter and poured her champagne, which were little things that Jenn found very refreshing after her past toxic relationships. In addition, Spencer has been the voice of reason among the men during their conflicts, reminding them that their focus should only be on Jenn. Jenn even said that he loved his “Golden Retriever energy.” If he doesn’t end up engaged to her, Spencer is the type of man who could definitely find love on Bachelor in Paradise.
7Jeremy Simon – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Jeremy Is Good-Natured & Funny
During The Bachelorette season 21 premiere night, Jeremy, a 29-year-old real estate investor from New York, New York, showed up in a red sports car rather than in the limousine. However, during his one-on-one time in the car with Jenn later that night, Brian Autz stole both Jenn and the car away from him. Rather than get into an argument with Brian and dwell on it, Jeremy maturely stepped away from the situation. Since then, whenever the guys have had conflicts, Jeremy lightens the mood with a funny comment, proving that he’s past the petty drama.
Jeremy has a romantic side as well, which he showed Jenn during the racecar group date. Despite the fact that he was supposed to be racing for the best time in order to win, Jeremy pulled the car over to give Jenn a kiss. It was an unexpected and romantic gesture that proved that Jeremy was in it to win it. With his maturity and readiness for a relationship, Jeremy would make a fantastic Bachelor in Paradise contestant if he doesn’t get engaged to Jenn at the end of her season.
8John Mitchell – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
John Has So Much Potential
John, a 25-year-old medical student from Delray Beach, Florida, hasn’t had as much time with Jenn as the other men, so Bachelor Nation hasn’t gotten to know him as well. However, the glimpses that viewers have gotten of John have proven that he’s very romantic. He even brought Jenn a plate of chocolates during a cocktail party just to make her feel special.
Jenn seems to have stronger relationships with the other men, so it’s highly possible that she’ll be saying goodbye to John soon. However, hopefully, that won’t be the last that Bachelor Nation sees of him. There’s so much more to learn about John, and he should have another chance on Bachelor in Paradise.John clearly has a lot of love to give, and it would be wonderful to see him get that opportunity on the beaches of Mexico.
9Hakeem Moulton – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Hakeem Is A Good Sport
Hakeem, a 29-year-old medical device salesman from Schaumberg, Illinois, was a great sport during his time on The Bachelorette season 21. Although he was terrified, during the wildlife photo shoot group date, he allowed a spider to walk on his hand. Hakeem also had a lot of fun driving the racecar with Jenn on their group date. He proved that he wasn’t afraid to come out of his comfort zone, and his strong reactions to those things were very memorable.
Although Jenn said goodbye to Hakeem, he left the show grateful for his experiences with her. He now deserves to find the love of his life on the beaches of Paradise. Hakeem would make a thoughtful and fun partner, who isn’t afraid to do what it takes to make a relationship work, even if it involves facing his worst fears. It would be a real treat to see him on Bachelor in Paradise.
10Sam Nejad – The Bachelorette Season 21 Contestant
Sam Has Never Been In Love
Sam, a 25-year-old entrepreneur from Carlsbad, California, came to The Bachelorette season 21 never having been in love. Although he jumped the gun a bit by telling Jenn that he was falling in love with her in front of everyone during the male stripper revue date (he said that he wanted to bare his soul instead of his body), Sam was sincerely trying to build his relationship with her.
Right before his elimination, Sam had built up his confidence during the rugby group date, after feeling insecure earlier in the season. He even had the courage to ask Jenn for a kiss, which would have been his first. However, she sent him home, saying in his confessional that she didn’t want to take that moment from him because she didn’t feel as strongly for her as he did for her. Sam deserves a chance to further explore love and romance on Bachelor in Paradise after opening up so much to Jenn during her season.
The Bachelorette season 21 cast was full of phenomenal guys who would make fantastic Bachelor in Paradise season 10 contestants. Although some of them are still in the running for Jenn’s heart, only one of them can win. The others should look for love on the beaches of Mexico during Bachelor in Paradise season 10.
