Scheana Shay once posted proof of story detailing John Mayer hookup: She ‘kept receipts’

She’s got locations and receipts.

Scheana Shay once posted a photo of a magazine that shared details of her alleged fling with John Mayer.

In 2018, a Reddit user shared a post that included a screenshot of a Snapchat Story that Shay shared at the time showing a page from a 2009 copy of Star magazine.

Scheana Shay smiling

Scheana Shay once posted proof of her alleged hookup with John Mayer. Getty Images

A screenshot of Scheana Shay's Snapchat Story showing John Mayer and Scheana Shay

A screenshot from Shay’s Snapchat Story in 2018 has resurfaced. Scheana/Snapchat

Jennifer Aniston and John Mayer posing together

The article was published shortly after he and Jennifer Aniston broke up in 2009. WireImage

The article included a photo of the “Daughters” singer on the top left and a picture of the “Vanderpump Rules” star on the bottom right.

“John’s new gal,” the headline read. “She’s 16 years younger than Jen!”

The headline was referring to Jennifer Aniston, who dated Mayer on and off for a year in 2008.

Scheana Shay posing for a photo

The story in Star magazine claimed the “Gravity” singer was “dating a model.” Instagram

John Mayer posing for a photo

Star reported that Shay was both “shocked and thrilled when John asked her out.” johnmayer/Instagram

The accompanying story detailed how Shay, now 38, and Mayer, now 46, hit it off and said she was “just a baby” compared to Aniston, now 55.

“‘Star’ has learned that John is hooking up with aspiring actress, Scheana Marie Jancan, who he met in early April at a Beverly Hills lounge. Scheana, who turns 24 in May, served the sexy singer drinks at The Grand Havana Room — the same place where he celebrates his 31st birthday with Jen! — and John started chatting her up,” the author wrote at the time.

The tabloid claimed Shay was both “shocked and thrilled when John asked her out.”

Scheana Shay on her phone

Shay’s Snapchat Story resurfaced after she insinuated she had an orgy with Mayer. Getty Images

John Mayer sitting on "WWHL"

The Grammy winner has kept tight-lipped on Shay’s claims. Charles Sykes/Bravo

Stay one step ahead with all the exclusive tea on your favorite reality TV stars!

Sign up for Virtual Reali-Tea with Danny and Evan, our must-read newsletter!

Shay posted the 2009 spread nine years later and added three laughing emojis to her Snapchat Story, according to the screenshot.

The post has also spread on X after Shay insinuated in a recent episode of “Vanderpump Rules” that she had an orgy with Mayer.

“Scheana kept receipts and shared this 5 years ago #PumpRules,” a fan account captioned a screenshot of the Reddit post Friday.

Scheana Shay sitting in a bikini

Shay previously recalled meeting Mayer at a party. scheana/Instagram

John Payer singing on stage

She claimed he later found her and asked for her number. Rosalind O’Connor/NBC

Shay’s claim about Mayer in last week’s episode of the Bravo reality series was not the first time she talked about their fling.

During an August 2020 episode of the “Flashbacks” podcast, she recalled “working this party” when she ended up “getting wasted” with both Mayer and Aniston.

“Every time they did a shot, they would get me a shot. Then [Aniston] invited me to go back to her place in the Palisades after for an afterparty,” she said at the time.

Scheana Shay posing on a carpet

The Bravolebrity revealed she was “fired” from her job because she wasn’t supposed to “fraternize” with members. Getty Images

John Mayer posing for a photo

The “Scheananigans” podcast host went on to claim that she was in a “throuple” with Mayer and her roommate at the time, “The Hills” star Stacie Adams. johnmayer/Instagram

Shay claimed she did not end up going to the “Friends” star’s house, but Mayer eventually saw her working again and allegedly asked for her phone number.

“I got fired because of it,” she alleged. “[My co-worker] went and looked at the New York member list and found out he wasn’t a member of Beverly Hills, but he was a member of New York, [and] we weren’t allowed to fraternize with members.”

The “Scheananigans” podcast host went on to claim that she was in a “throuple” with Mayer and her roommate at the time, “The Hills” star Stacie Adams.

Scheana Shay talking on "Vanderpump Rules"

Shay admitted to being “jealous” of Adams. Bravo

Scheana Shay taking a selfie

She didn’t elaborate on why they didn’t work out. scheana/Instagram

“We would go to his house in Calabasas or Hidden Hills, whatever it’s called. It just became, you know, kind of the three of us. We had a little throuple going on,” she claimed, confirming it was “sexual.”

Shay did not specify why she and Mayer fizzled out, but she did admit to being “jealous” of Adams because he “liked” her more and the two “continued talking” after she and the Grammy winner were over.

Despite previously talking about her rendezvous with Mayer, Shay sent shockwaves through the Bravoverse last Tuesday when she hinted at having an orgy with him.

Scheana Shay talking on "Vanderpump Rules"

Shay sent shockwaves through the Bravoverse last week when she hinted at having an orgy with Mayer. Bravo

Scheana Shay, Ariana Madix, Lala Kent laughing

She even referenced his hit song “Your Body Is a Wonderland.” Casey Durkin/Bravo

“Once upon a time, my body was a wonderland,” she said in a confessional, referring to his hit song “Your Body Is a Wonderland,” after admitting to having an orgy with an “A-list celebrity.”

Mayer has not addressed the comment, but a source told the US Sun that he is “annoyed” that Shay talked about him on TV.

 

“John has told several people close to him that he never hooked up with Scheana,” an insider told the outlet.

The source added that the heartthrob “wants nothing to do with her.”

Scheana shay kissing brock davies

Mayer, not pictured, is reportedly “annoyed” with Shay. OConnor-Arroyo / AFF-USA.com / MEGA

Brock Davies and Scheana Shay posing with their daughter

Shay has since married Brock Davies, and they share a daughter together. scheana/Instagram

Neither Shay nor Mayer’s reps returned Page Six’s requests for comment.

Mayer has since dated a slew of A-listers — including Taylor Swift and Katy Perry — but he is currently single.

Meanwhile, Shay married Brock Davies in 2022, and they share a 2-year-old daughter named Summer Moon.

Related Posts

‘Bachelor’ star reveals ‘sho.cking’ symptom that led to m.e.ni.ngitis diagnosis

“The Bachelor” alum Daisy Kent experienced one symptom prior to her meningitis diagnosis that made her realize her health was going to take a turn for the worse….

Pregnant Lindsay Hubbard Gets W.a.r.ning From Doctor As She Approaches Her 3rd Trimester

Lindsay Hubbard revealed that her doctor told her to slow down on her pregnancy weight gain. In August 2024, the “Summer House” star, who announced she was pregnant on July 4, took…

The Bachelor: Kelsey Anderson Changed Up Her Signature Hairstyle (Does Joey Graziadei Like Her Glamorous New Look?)

The Bachelor season 28’s Kelsey Anderson has changed her signature hairstyle, but what does Joey Graziadei think about her glamorous new look? 25-year-old Kelsey made her television debut on night…

Pedro Pascal tells reporter he’d ‘shove’ her out of the way to get to Rihanna

When it comes to loving Rihanna, the “Last of Us” star is just like the rest of us. Pedro Pascal is going viral after telling a reporter…

Tales of the Walking Dead’s Danny Ramirez cast in new movie, Pursuit of Touch

Actor Danny Ramirez is well known for his roles in Top Gun: Maverick and the Disney+ series The Falcon and the Winter Soldier. Walking Dead fans know him as Eric from the season final…

Jake Paul filmed absolutely steaming after celebrating team USA’s basketball win

The United States men’s basketball were crowned Olympic champions for a fifth consecutive time. Following the win, YouTuber turned boxer, Jake Paul was filmed leaving a party…